Nouncil Vote:
31 Yes, 30 No, 1 Abstain
8 Nouncillors abstained from the decision
YES WINS
Vote Reasons & Discussion
vsvsvs | "How had this not already been in place -- my first Hell yess"
Josep | "Amazing idea, Nouns gets lot of transactions and this would be helpfull."
Brook | "the provision of 1 Ξ for suggesting an idea sets an interesting precedent. wonder what it means for upcoming props such as prop 194"
lilpizza.eth | "great idea, but the 1 eth bounty for it seems excessive. I would vote yes without it."
JoelCares | "1 ETH feels excessive here."
pemburux | "I agree with the idea, but for the value of 1 ETH I can't agree with it yet"
andreitr | "Love the simplicity and utility of this proposal but voting against it - I am concerned about the precedent 1ETH compensation sets for the future props."
0xDariush | "I love to see that but agree with you all, 1 Eth make no sense for a simple transaction and I don't call it an idea to be honest.
But I'm wondering why they didn't set the ENS til now anyway
I see foundation.nouns.eth
0x37b8e20646d174b00198b7e183dd1f25520c0f60
owns that ENS at the moment."
kerimbonia | "i'm all for compensating nouns contributors for their time and ideas, but a 1eth tip is a bit exaggerated. if there was some breakdown of time spent working on the prop with reference to how others have been compensated in the past for similar ideas or work, i think the 'tip' could be justified."
JoshuaFisher | "idea is cool but why the extra 1eth fee haha"
Benbodhi | "I like the idea and rewarding ideas but feel like 1 eth for it might be a bit high. Especially considering that a second version of this prop went up without the reward."
Mindtoasted | "The idea is simple but for 1 eth it's kinda hard to agree on this, IMO it just less reasonable"
For more Nouns DAO proposal discussion head to the Nouncil Discord: https://discord.gg/nouncil